If you live in a community governed by a Homeowners’ Association (HOA) in California, there’s some significant news you need to know. Buried within the recent state budget legislation (Assembly Bill 130) are major reforms to the Davis-Stirling Act that directly impact how HOAs can levy fines against homeowners.
Gone are the days of worrying about open-ended, financially crushing penalties for minor violations. A new law, effective immediately, brings common-sense limits and new homeowner protections to the enforcement process.
Let’s break down the three key changes to Civil Code §§ 5850 and 5855.
1. The $100 Cap on Most HOA Fines
What Changed: This is the headline reform. Previously, an HOA’s schedule of penalties could theoretically include very high fines for violations. The new law states that a monetary penalty for a violation of the governing documents cannot exceed the lesser of the amount in the HOA’s existing schedule or $100 per violation.
What It Means for You: Whether your HOA’s rules say $50 or $500 for a misplaced trash can, fence repair, etc. the maximum they can now fine you is $100 per incident. This creates a crucial financial ceiling for homeowners.
The Exception: There is an important caveat. An HOA can impose a fine higher than $100 if the violation results in an “adverse health or safety impact.” However, the HOA board must first make a written finding at a public meeting specifying what that health or safety impact is. This exception is meant for serious issues, not for minor aesthetic violations.
2. The Right to “Cure” a Violation First
What Changed: The old rules required an HOA to notify you 10 days before a meeting to consider discipline. Now, the law explicitly states that a member must have the opportunity to cure the violation prior to that meeting.
What It Means for You: If you receive a notice about a violation, like a fence that needs painting or a boat parked in the driveway you now have a legal right to fix the problem before ever being formally penalized. If you correct the issue within that timeframe, the board cannot impose discipline or a fine for that violation. This promotes compliance over punishment.
3. A Faster (Slightly) Formal Notice
What Changed: The law has shortened the deadline for the HOA to provide you with written notification of a final decision to impose discipline.
What It Means for You: After the board meeting, the HOA now has 14 days instead of 15 to get you the official notice. While a single day may seem minor, it reflects the law’s intent to streamline the process and prevent delays that can create uncertainty for homeowners.
What This All Means for California Homeowners
The legislature has sent a clear message:
- Proportionality is Key: Fines should be proportionate to the offense. A $100 cap prevents fines from becoming a revenue source or a tool for harassment over minor issues.
- Compliance Over Punishment: The “right to cure” ensures the goal is to maintain community standards, not to trap residents with fines. It gives homeowners a chance to correct an honest mistake without financial penalty.
- Clarity and Certainty: These new rules provide clearer guardrails for both HOAs and homeowners, reducing the potential for disputes and legal conflicts
What Should You Do?
- Be Aware: Understand your rights under these new laws.
- Review Your HOA’s Policies: Your HOA’s board should be updating its governing documents and fine schedules to comply with this state law. If they haven’t already, they will need to soon.
- Communicate: If you receive a violation notice, remember you likely have the right to fix the issue first without a fine and that there is a cap to the fines allowed.
These changes are a major win for homeowner rights in California. By instating a reasonable cap on fines and formalizing the right to correct a violation, the law helps ensure that HOAs act fairly and their rules are enforced justly
